Which one should I choose: Cerebelly Organic White Bean Pumpkin Apple Puree, 4 oz pouch or Gerber Stage 2 Organic Banana Blueberry Blackberry Oatmeal pouch?

I'd start with Gerber Gerber Stage 2 Organic Banana Blueberry Blackberry Oatmeal pouch - it scored 8.6/10 overall in our scoring system. Safety is our top-weighted scoring pillar, followed by efficacy, and usability. Check which pillar matters most to your family and compare those specific scores.

How does R3 score Baby Food products?

We use the same scoring system on every product, weighted across three pillars: safety, efficacy, and usability. Every score is reproducible, so the same product data always produces the same score, and each product is evaluated across multiple criteria within each pillar.

Is the higher-scoring Baby Food the right pick for me?

Not necessarily. The overall score reflects how we weight those three pillars, but your priorities may differ. If you care most about safety, compare the safety scores directly. If budget drives your decision, the prices tell a clearer story. The "right" pick is the one that matches what matters most to your family.

Cerebelly Organic White Bean Pumpkin Apple Puree, 4 oz pouch vs…

Cerebelly Organic White Bean Pumpkin Apple Puree, 4 oz pouch vs… | R3

How They Compare

Safety

Per-batch results published by lot codeHeavy-Metal Testing Disclosure

-Heavy-Metal Testing Disclosure

YesTests Finished Product

Not captured for this lotMeasured Lead Level

-Measured Lead Level

Not captured for this lotMeasured Inorganic Arsenic Level

-Measured Inorganic Arsenic Level

Not captured for this lotMeasured Cadmium Level

-Measured Cadmium Level

Not captured for this lotMeasured Mercury Level

-Measured Mercury Level

Not tested or disclosedPerchlorate Tested or Disclosed

-Perchlorate Tested or Disclosed

None on recordActive Recall or FDA Warning

NoActive Recall or FDA Warning

Moderate (white bean and pumpkin base)Primary Ingredient Contamination Risk

-Primary Ingredient Contamination Risk

-Heavy-Metals Testing Disclosure (AB 899 Tier)

Per-batch results publishedHeavy-Metals Testing Disclosure (AB 899 Tier)

YesTests Finished Product (Not Just Ingredients)

-Measured / Disclosed Lead Level

At or below 1 ppbMeasured / Disclosed Lead Level

-Measured / Disclosed Inorganic Arsenic Level

About 1 ppbMeasured / Disclosed Inorganic Arsenic Level

-Measured / Disclosed Cadmium Level

At or below 1 ppbMeasured / Disclosed Cadmium Level

-Measured / Disclosed Mercury Level

At or below 1 ppbMeasured / Disclosed Mercury Level

-Perchlorate Tested / Disclosed

Not publishedPerchlorate Tested / Disclosed

NoActive Recall / FDA Warning Status

NoneActive Recall / FDA Warning Status

-Primary Ingredient Contamination-Risk Class

Moderate (fruit-led, oat fourth)Primary Ingredient Contamination-Risk Class

Nutrition

YesProvides Meaningful Iron

No (0.3 mg, 2% daily value)Provides Meaningful Iron

Stage 2 combinationDevelopmental Stage Labeling

Stage 2 combinationsDevelopmental Stage Labeling

NoneAdded Sugar

NoneAdded Salt

Cooked, blended, shelf-stable pureeDegree of Processing

Cooked, blended, shelf-stableDegree of Processing

Convenience

Squeeze pouchFood Format

BPA-free multilayer pouchPackaging Material

Plastic pouch (material not disclosed)Packaging Material

Who Should Buy What

Everything you need to make the call - who each one is for, and who should skip it.

Go for it if you...

You want a brand that publishes its own batch heavy-metal testing and lets you look it up by lot code
You are feeding a Stage 2 baby and want a combination pouch with no added sugar or salt
You value meaningful iron in a pouch and will check the lot-lookup results yourself
You rotate beans, vegetables, and grains across your baby's week rather than relying on one base

You want a fruit-and-oat pouch from a brand that lets you check the tested metal results for the exact lot you bought
You are deliberately steering away from rice-based cereals to keep arsenic exposure lower
You value being able to scan a code and see real lead, arsenic, mercury, and cadmium numbers instead of a general safety claim
You need a no-prep, shelf-stable option for daycare bags, travel, or quick snacks

The main thing to know

Cerebelly tests every batch and publishes the results, but the parts-per-billion readings live behind its lot-lookup tool, so we could not record a published number for this specific flavor and lot. We hold those four heavy-metal readings at neutral, which means nothing concerning was found and nothing was confirmed clean. Enter the lot code on your pouch to see the figures for the food you bought.

This pouch is not an iron source, listing about 0.3 milligrams, so it does not help meet the iron a baby needs once solids begin. Pair it with iron-rich foods rather than leaning on it for that.

Skip this if you...

You want a single published parts-per-billion number for each heavy metal printed on the page before you buy
You want perchlorate included in the brand's published testing panel
You prefer a green-vegetable or meat base over a bean-and-squash one for the lowest-risk ingredients

You are counting on a single pouch to cover your baby's iron, since this one provides almost none
You want packaging with a stated liner material and a confirmed BPA-free claim
You prefer a brand that also publishes a perchlorate result, which this portal does not include

Cerebelly Organic White Bean Pumpkin Apple Puree, 4 oz pouch vs Gerber Stage 2 Organic Banana Blueberry Blackberry Oatmeal pouch

Quick Look

The Details

Full Specifications