How we score

Appalachian Cast Iron Appalachian Cast Iron Great American… | R3

Independent, non-toxic product reviews for families who research.

Reviews & research

Product reviews
Compare products
Buying Guides
Research
Safety Dictionary
How we score

Popular categories

Water Filter
Kids Backpack
Kids Vitamins
Kids Snacks
Air Purifier

Company

About
Pricing
Contact
For Brands

Legal

Privacy
Terms
Affiliate disclosure

Fully independent

2,000+ citations verified

Research-verified

91+ Categories

925+ products safety-scored

We do the research. You get the picks.

Non-toxic picks, safety alerts, and research updates — straight to your inbox.

Facebook Instagram X (formerly Twitter)

TikTok

YouTube

Waffle-Maker/Appalachian Cast Iron

Appalachian Cast Iron

Appalachian Cast Iron Great American Waffle Iron

#5 of 6 waffle-makers tested

6.1/10

Fair

There are better options - here's why.

8.7Safety

safety50%

8.7/10

efficacy26%

6/10

usability24%

1/10

R3 Verified

No image

$89.99

Buy on Amazon

Affiliate link - doesn't affect our scores

Independently tested

4-criteria rubric

No brand influence

Updated Mar 2026

The bottom line

Here's what I'd tell a friend

What you should know first

Appalachian Cast Iron Great American Waffle Iron: 6.13/10 (Fair). Safety 8.65/10, Efficacy 6/10, Usability 1/10.

Go for it if...

PFAS-free food-contact surfaces are a priority for your household

Maybe skip if...

You have specific requirements this product does not meet

Where to buy

Verified retailer with current pricing

Appalachian Cast Iron Great American Waffle Iron6.1/10

$89.99Buy

$89.99

Verified Live price

View on Amazon

We may earn a commission from purchases through our links. It doesn't affect our scores and helps keep R3 free and independent.

Safety research

Materials, certifications, and what the testing actually shows

8.7/10

Safety score

PFAS-Free

Not confirmed

What our rubric found

R3 independently researches materials, certifications, and chemical testing. Our scores can't be influenced by brands.

How we score Safety Dictionary

How we scored it

4 criteria weighted by what matters most for families

Plate SafetyCritical

50%

8.7▼

What we looked at

Plate Material & Coating

pre-seasoned cast iron10/10

Safety Certifications

1/10

Cooking CapacityCritical

26%

6▼

What we looked at

Waffles Per Cooking Cycle

16/10

Ownership ExperienceCritical

24%

1▼

What we looked at

Removable Cooking Plates

-1/10

Dishwasher-Safe Plates

-1/10

Warranty Coverage

-1/10

Price vs. QualityImportant

1▼

What we looked at

Price per R3 Point

-1/10

Read the full methodology

Other Options to Consider

Alternatives that address specific trade-offs

Why this matters: This product scores 1.0/10 on ownership experience

Better ownership experience

GreenPan Elite 4-Square Belgian Waffle Maker

GreenPan

8.7$119.99

This product scores 1.0/10 on ownership experience

Better ownership experience

GreenPan Elite 2-Square Belgian Waffle Maker

GreenPan

8.2$79.99

This product scores 1.0/10 on ownership experience

Better ownership experience

Hamilton Beach Belgian Waffle Maker 26031

Hamilton Beach

7.6$44.99

This product scores 1.0/10 on ownership experience

Better ownership experience

GreenPan Stainless Steel 2-Square Waffle Maker

GreenPan

6.5$59.99

This product scores 1.0/10 on ownership experience

Didn't find the waffle-maker you need?

See all waffle-makers we reviewed

Last reviewed: March 2026

V4.2 - appalachian-cast-iron-waffle-iron