The Quick Answer

  • Both are safe, physical sunblocks that sit on top of the skin rather than absorbing into the bloodstream (unlike chemical filters like Oxybenzone). However, Non-Nano Zinc Oxide is vastly superior. Zinc provides complete broad-spectrum protection against BOTH UVA and UVB rays, whereas Titanium Dioxide only protects deeply against UVB. Look for sunscreens using 20% or higher Non-Nano Zinc Oxide as their sole active ingredient.
Editor's NoteWe strictly recommend against the use of chemical UV filters based on FDA absorption studies showing high bloodstream retention.

How Physical Sunscreens Work

Chemical sunscreens (containing oxybenzone, avobenzone, etc.) absorb into the bloodstream and act as chemical sponges, absorbing UV light. The FDA recently admitted they do not have enough data to prove these chemicals are safe, and studies show they disrupt hormones.

Physical (mineral) sunscreens act as microscopic mirrors. They sit on the surface of your baby's skin and bounce the UV rays away. There are only two FDA-approved physical filters: Zinc Oxide and Titanium Dioxide.

“If the sunscreen absorbs instantly and leaves no white cast, it is likely using chemical filters or microscopic nanoparticles. True safety often leaves a slight white hue.”

— Renee Says

Section Summary

  • Mineral sunscreens reflect light; chemical sunscreens absorb light.
  • Zinc and Titanium are the only two approved physical filters.
  • Chemical filters are absorbed into the infant's bloodstream.

Why Zinc Wins

The sun emits two types of damaging rays: UVB (which burns) and UVA (which ages and mutates DNA deep in the skin).

Titanium Dioxide is excellent at blocking UVB rays but falls short on the deeper UVA rays. Zinc Oxide, however, is the only UV filter on the earth that provides sweeping, complete protection across the entire UVA and UVB spectrum all by itself.

Additionally, Zinc is a highly soothing skin mineral (it is the primary ingredient in Diaper Rash cream), making it actively beneficial for sensitive baby eczema.

Section Summary

  • Zinc Oxide blocks the entire UVA and UVB spectrum.
  • Titanium Dioxide misses parts of the UVA spectrum.
  • Zinc helps soothe eczema and rash-prone skin.

The "Non-Nano" Requirement

Because pure Zinc Oxide leaves a thick white ghost-paste on the skin, chemists figured out a trick: pulverize the zinc into microscopic "nanoparticles." If the particles are small enough, the sunscreen rubs in clear!

The problem? Particles that small can potentially pass through the skin barrier and enter the bloodstream, or be deeply inhaled if using a spray. To guarantee the zinc stays on the surface of the skin where it belongs, you must buy sunscreen explicitly labeled "Non-Nano."

Section Summary

  • Nanoparticles rub in clear but can penetrate the skin barrier.
  • Non-Nano particles are large enough to safely stay on the surface.

1 more tips

Create a free account to see more buying advice

Sign Up Free

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about toxicology: cosmetics answered by our research team.

QIs it safe to use sunscreen on a newborn?

The AAP recommends avoiding all sunscreen for babies under 6 months old because their skin is highly absorptive and they lack the ability to sweat efficiently. Use UPF clothing, wide hats, and strict shade instead. If unavoidable, use a tiny amount of mineral zinc on small exposed areas like the face and hands.

R

Renee, R3 Founder

Environmental Toxins Analyst

Renee is the founder of R3 and a lead researcher in environmental toxins. She specializes in translating complex toxicology reports into actionable advice for families.

LinkedInX (Twitter)Editorial Standards