Head-to-Head Comparison
Lodge Cast Iron Skillet 10.25" vs Victoria Cast Iron Skillet 12"
Two excellent Cookware options compared. Lodge and Victoria both deliver strong performance with different strengths—your choice depends on your specific priorities.
Lodge
Cast Iron Skillet 10.25"
9.1
$35VS
Victoria
Cast Iron Skillet 12"
9.0
$38R3 Research Verdict
Two excellent Cookware options compared. Lodge and Victoria both deliver strong performance with different strengths—your choice depends on your specific priorities.
Updated Feb 20, 20266 attributes comparedBy R3 Research Team
Too Close to Call—Choose Based on Your Priorities
Research-backed recommendation
The Bottom Line
Both Lodge and Victoria are excellent Cookware options. With scores within 0.3 points of each other, the "winner" truly depends on your specific needs:
Choose Lodge if:
- ["Clean-Living Community: Mamavation-recommended, truly non-toxic", "Value Seekers: $35 for cookware that lasts generations", "Searing Enthusiasts: unmatched heat retention for perfect crusts", "Outdoor Cooks: safe for campfires, grills, and open flames"]
- Value is your top priority
Choose Victoria if:
- ["Clean Living Community: absolutely nothing to worry about - just iron", "Reddit Cast Iron Fans: the community-recommended upgrade from Lodge", "Value Seekers: premium surface finish at commodity pricing", "Serious Searing: heavy mass provides excellent heat retention"]
- You want a solid alternative
Our Take
When products are this close in quality, consider factors like availability, your existing brand preferences, and any specific features that matter to your family. You can't go wrong with either choice.
Both products are excellent choices - your decision depends on your specific priorities.
Pros & Cons at a Glance
Quick summary of each product's strengths and weaknesses
Lodge
Cast Iron Skillet 10.25"
Pros
- Better Overall Score
- Better Value Score
- Better Price
Cons
- Loses on Efficacy Score
Victoria
Cast Iron Skillet 12"
Pros
- Better Efficacy Score
Cons
- Loses on Overall Score
- Loses on Value Score
- Loses on Price
Who Wins Each Category?
A quick breakdown of how these products compare head-to-head
Overall Score
Lodge
Win
R3 composite score based on safety, efficacy, and value
Safety Score
Tie
Based on ingredient analysis, certifications, and third-party testing
Efficacy Score
Victoria
Win
Based on performance metrics and real-world effectiveness
Value Score
Lodge
Win
Based on price-to-performance ratio and long-term cost
Price
Lodge
Win
Lower price wins for budget-conscious shoppers
Brand
Tie
Both are established brands in this category
Winner
Tie
Which One Is Right For You?
Personalized recommendations based on your priorities
Buy Lodge If You...
- ["Clean-Living Community: Mamavation-recommended, truly non-toxic", "Value Seekers: $35 for cookware that lasts generations", "Searing Enthusiasts: unmatched heat retention for perfect crusts", "Outdoor Cooks: safe for campfires, grills, and open flames"]
- Budget-conscious families who want quality without overpaying
- Parents who prioritize safety above all else
Buy Victoria If You...
- ["Clean Living Community: absolutely nothing to worry about - just iron", "Reddit Cast Iron Fans: the community-recommended upgrade from Lodge", "Value Seekers: premium surface finish at commodity pricing", "Serious Searing: heavy mass provides excellent heat retention"]
- Budget-conscious families who want quality without overpaying
- Parents who prioritize safety above all else
- Those who want maximum performance and effectiveness
Head-to-Head Comparison
Detailed attribute-by-attribute breakdown
Lodge
vs3
Victoria
(2 ties)1
| Attribute | Lodge | Victoria | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Overall Score R3 composite score based on safety, efficacy, and value | 9.1/10 | 9.0/10 | Lodge |
| Safety Score Based on ingredient analysis, certifications, and third-party testing | 9.8/10 | 9.8/10 | Tie |
| Efficacy Score Based on performance metrics and real-world effectiveness | 8.8/10 | 9.0/10 | Victoria |
| Value Score Based on price-to-performance ratio and long-term cost | 9.5/10 | 9.3/10 | Lodge |
| Price Lower price wins for budget-conscious shoppers | $34.99 | $37.99 | Lodge |
| Brand Both are established brands in this category | Lodge | Victoria | Tie |
Lodge
3 Wins
Victoria
1 Wins
Overall Score
Lodge
9.1/10
9.0/10
R3 composite score based on safety, efficacy, and value
Safety Score
Tie
9.8/10
9.8/10
Based on ingredient analysis, certifications, and third-party testing
Efficacy Score
Victoria
8.8/10
9.0/10
Based on performance metrics and real-world effectiveness
Value Score
Lodge
9.5/10
9.3/10
Based on price-to-performance ratio and long-term cost
Price
Lodge
$34.99
$37.99
Lower price wins for budget-conscious shoppers
Brand
Tie
Lodge
Victoria
Both are established brands in this category
$Price Analysis
Both products are priced similarly at around $36. Price shouldn't be a deciding factor between these two options.
Best Time to Buy
Check for sales during major shopping holidays like Black Friday, Prime Day, or seasonal clearances. Many brands also offer discounts when signing up for their newsletters.
Create a free account to preview premium reviews
Get 3 free premium previews per week with a free account
Research-backed product recommendations
Transparent methodology and citations
No ads or affiliate influence
Already have an account? Log in
Independent Research
No sponsored placements. Data-driven verdicts.
1,000+ data points
Updated February 20, 2026
R
R3 Research Team
•Evidence-Based Review BoardOur multidisciplinary team of researchers, parents, and medical advisors dedicated to finding the safest products for your family.
Explore More Comparisons
Find the perfect product with our research-backed head-to-head showdowns.
