Breville Milk Café BMF600XL vs Secura 4-in-1 Automatic Milk Frother 17oz

The jug is full stainless steel with no interior coating, so there's nothing that can chip, flake, or degrade into your milk over time. Hot milk sits directly against inert metal — a material that doesn't react at frothing temperatures. Milk can stick slightly if you let it sit, but a quick rinse clears it completely.

The jug interior is 304 stainless steel with no coating — nothing to chip, flake, or wear off into your milk over time. Hot milk sits against inert metal from pour to finish. The tradeoff: milk can stick slightly with hot chocolate or high-fat dairy, but a quick rinse handles it completely.

ETL Listed means the frother passed electrical safety testing — it won't shock you or start a fire. It doesn't tell you anything about the materials touching your food. There's no food-contact certification (like NSF or FDA compliance declaration) listed for this product.

ETL Listed means the frother meets US and Canadian electrical safety standards — it's been tested by an independent lab for things like overheating and electrical faults. You won't find food-contact material certifications (like PFAS-free testing) on this one. For a $40 frother, ETL is the baseline you want to see.

Five modes covers every format you'd actually make: dense cappuccino foam, latte microfoam, cold foam, hot milk, and hot chocolate. You won't need to work around the frother to get the drink you want. First-time setup takes a few extra minutes to learn which disc and setting to use for each drink.

Four modes covers the standard family coffee routine: hot foam, cold foam, hot milk, and a specialty mode (typically hot chocolate). You won't find a dedicated microfoam setting for latte art or a low-temperature mode tuned for oat or almond milk. For straight lattes and cappuccinos, four modes is plenty.

You get adjustable temperature control, which no basic frother offers. That matters for plant-based milks, which scorch at dairy temps, and for anyone who prefers a cooler latte. The presets get you close — for most drinks, a few degrees off your ideal temperature is undetectable.

Temperature is fixed — you can't lower it for plant-based milks, which scorch more easily than whole milk at high heat. If oat or almond milk is your daily driver, expect occasional scorching and more frequent cleaning. Whole milk and 2% work fine at a fixed temperature.

At 17oz, you can froth enough milk for two drinks in a single cycle. That covers most households through the morning routine without waiting for a second batch. If three or more people all want frothed drinks at once, you're running a second cycle — about 3-4 extra minutes.

At 17oz, you can froth two drinks per cycle without refilling — practical for a household of two. If three or more people want frothed drinks at the same time, you're running a second cycle, which adds 3-4 minutes. For most families, one cycle covers the morning routine.

The jug is dishwasher-safe, so cleanup is done when you load the machine. No hand-scrubbing milk residue out of a coated jug. With stainless steel, you don't have to worry about dishwasher cycles wearing down a coating.

The jug is dishwasher-safe, so cleanup is hands-off. Stainless steel holds up to repeated dishwasher cycles without any coating to worry about degrading. This is one less thing to hand-wash.

You get a 1-year warranty — the industry standard, and the minimum. It covers manufacturing defects but nothing beyond that. At $99.95 and used daily, any motor or heating failure in year two comes out of your pocket.

Two years covers the most common failure window for daily-use frothers — motor wear and heating element issues typically show up in year one or two. After the warranty expires, repair costs on budget frothers usually exceed the cost of a replacement. It's better than a one-year warranty, but don't expect it to cover year three of daily use.

Auto-shutoff means the frother turns itself off when the cycle finishes or the milk reaches temperature. You don't have to stand over it, and there's no risk of scorched milk if you get distracted. It's a basic safety feature, but one you should expect on any frother at this price.

Auto-shutoff means the frother turns itself off when frothing is complete — no scorched milk if you step away, no safety risk if you forget it's running. This is standard on quality frothers and worth confirming before you buy.