Head-to-Head Comparison
Our Place Wonder Oven vs Ninja AF161: Premium Safety vs Amazon's Bestseller
This comparison pits R3's top pick (Our Place) against Amazon's perennial bestseller (Ninja AF161). Both are solid choices, but they serve different families. Our Place costs $65 more ($195 vs $130) and delivers genuinely PFAS-free stainless steel construction plus steam infusion tech—features Ninja can't match. Ninja counters with 18,000 verified reviews proving consistent performance, Max Crisp Technology that cooks 30% faster, and a dishwasher-safe basket. Our Place wins on materials transparency and versatility (toasts + steam infusion). Ninja wins on proven reliability and ease of cleaning. If you're choosing between these two, the question is: Does PFAS-free matter enough to spend $65 more?
Winner
Our Place
Our Place Wonder Oven - 6-in-1 Air Fryer Toaster Oven
7.6
$195VS
Ninja
Ninja AF161 Max XL Air Fryer
7.8
$130R3 Research Verdict
This comparison pits R3's top pick (Our Place) against Amazon's perennial bestseller (Ninja AF161). Both are solid choices, but they serve different families. Our Place costs $65 more ($195 vs $130) and delivers genuinely PFAS-free stainless steel construction plus steam infusion tech—features Ninja can't match. Ninja counters with 18,000 verified reviews proving consistent performance, Max Crisp Technology that cooks 30% faster, and a dishwasher-safe basket. Our Place wins on materials transparency and versatility (toasts + steam infusion). Ninja wins on proven reliability and ease of cleaning. If you're choosing between these two, the question is: Does PFAS-free matter enough to spend $65 more?
Updated Jan 22, 20266 attributes comparedBy R3 Research Team
Safety Premium vs Proven Performance
Research-backed recommendation
Our Place Wonder Oven earns R3's pick because it solves the problem most air fryers won't admit exists: What IS that non-stick coating? Ninja's proprietary coating performs well (18,000 reviews prove it), but 'PFOA-free' doesn't tell you what they're using instead—likely still a PTFE variant. Our Place's stainless steel interior costs $65 more, but you're buying transparency and the peace of mind that comes with genuinely PFAS-free materials. Ninja wins on proven reliability (years of consistent reviews vs Our Place's newer market presence) and dishwasher-safe convenience. For families deep in the non-toxic rabbit hole, spend the extra $65. For everyone else, Ninja's track record and lower price make it the smarter buy.
Pros & Cons at a Glance
Quick summary of each product's strengths and weaknesses
Our Place
Our Place Wonder Oven - 6-in-1 Air Fryer Toaster Oven
Winner
Pros
- Better Materials Safety
- Better Versatility
- Better Preheat Speed
Cons
- Loses on Proven Track Record
- Loses on Cleanup
- Loses on Price
Ninja
Ninja AF161 Max XL Air Fryer
Pros
- Better Proven Track Record
- Better Cleanup
- Better Price
Cons
- Loses on Materials Safety
- Loses on Versatility
- Loses on Preheat Speed
Who Wins Each Category?
A quick breakdown of how these products compare head-to-head
Materials Safety
Our Place
Win
Our Place wins transparency—Ninja won't disclose coating beyond 'PFOA-free'
Proven Track Record
Ninja
Win
Ninja's massive review database proves consistent quality over years
Versatility
Our Place
Win
Our Place adds toasting and steam infusion—replaces 3 appliances vs Ninja's air fryer-only focus
Preheat Speed
Our Place
Win
Our Place heats faster (75% quicker than traditional ovens)
Cleanup
Ninja
Win
Ninja's dishwasher-safe basket wins for busy families
Price
Ninja
Win
Ninja costs $65 less—significant savings for similar capacity
Winner
Tie
Which One Is Right For You?
Personalized recommendations based on your priorities
Buy Our Place If You...Winner
- Families prioritizing PFAS-free materials over price
- Users who want toasting + air frying in one compact appliance
- Parents who research ingredient labels and materials safety
- Buyers who value steam infusion for juicier leftovers
- Aesthetic-conscious users (11 color options)
Buy Ninja If You...
- Budget-conscious families ($65 savings)
- Users who trust 18,000+ verified reviews over new products
- Busy families who want dishwasher-safe cleanup
- Buyers prioritizing Max Crisp Technology (30% faster)
- First-time air fryer users wanting proven reliability
Head-to-Head Comparison
Detailed attribute-by-attribute breakdown
Our Place
vs3
Ninja
3
| Attribute | Our Place | Ninja | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Materials Safety Our Place wins transparency—Ninja won't disclose coating beyond 'PFOA-free' | 100% PFAS-free stainless steel interior | Proprietary non-stick (undisclosed, 'PFOA-free') | Our Place |
| Proven Track Record Ninja's massive review database proves consistent quality over years | Newer product, limited long-term reviews | 18,000+ verified reviews at 4.6 stars | Ninja |
| Versatility Our Place adds toasting and steam infusion—replaces 3 appliances vs Ninja's air fryer-only focus | 6-in-1 + toast + steam infusion | 7-in-1 (no toasting or steam) | Our Place |
| Preheat Speed Our Place heats faster (75% quicker than traditional ovens) | Under 2.5 minutes | ~3-4 minutes | Our Place |
| Cleanup Ninja's dishwasher-safe basket wins for busy families | Hand-wash only accessories | Dishwasher-safe basket + easy cleanup | Ninja |
| Price Ninja costs $65 less—significant savings for similar capacity | $195 | $130 | Ninja |
Our Place
3 Wins
Ninja
3 Wins
Materials Safety
Our Place
100% PFAS-free stainless steel interior
Proprietary non-stick (undisclosed, 'PFOA-free')
Our Place wins transparency—Ninja won't disclose coating beyond 'PFOA-free'
Proven Track Record
Ninja
Newer product, limited long-term reviews
18,000+ verified reviews at 4.6 stars
Ninja's massive review database proves consistent quality over years
Versatility
Our Place
6-in-1 + toast + steam infusion
7-in-1 (no toasting or steam)
Our Place adds toasting and steam infusion—replaces 3 appliances vs Ninja's air fryer-only focus
Preheat Speed
Our Place
Under 2.5 minutes
~3-4 minutes
Our Place heats faster (75% quicker than traditional ovens)
Cleanup
Ninja
Hand-wash only accessories
Dishwasher-safe basket + easy cleanup
Ninja's dishwasher-safe basket wins for busy families
Price
Ninja
$195
$130
Ninja costs $65 less—significant savings for similar capacity
$Price Analysis
Ninja costs $130 vs Our Place's $195—a $65 difference. That premium buys stainless steel construction, steam infusion, and toasting capability. Ninja offers 18,000 proven reviews and dishwasher-safe convenience. If PFAS-free matters, the $65 is worth it. If proven performance and budget matter, Ninja wins.
Best Time to Buy
Ninja frequently goes on sale during Amazon Prime Day ($99-109) and Black Friday ($89-99). Our Place runs 100-day trials year-round. For budget buyers, wait for Ninja sales (save $30-40). For safety-focused families, buy Our Place at full price—the materials transparency justifies $195.
Create a free account to preview premium reviews
Get 3 free premium previews per week with a free account
Research-backed product recommendations
Transparent methodology and citations
No ads or affiliate influence
Already have an account? Log in
Independent Research
No sponsored placements. Data-driven verdicts.
1,000+ data points
Updated January 22, 2026
R
R3 Research Team
•Evidence-Based Review BoardOur multidisciplinary team of researchers, parents, and medical advisors dedicated to finding the safest products for your family.
Explore More Comparisons
Find the perfect product with our research-backed head-to-head showdowns.
