Head-to-Head Comparison
Once Upon a Farm vs MadeGood: Clean Kids Snacks Showdown
Both deliver on clean ingredients, but Once Upon a Farm edges ahead with just 4-5 whole food ingredients and 3g sugar versus MadeGood's 5g. MadeGood wins on value ($0.72 vs $1.75) and allergen safety. Your choice depends on ingredient purity versus budget and school restrictions.
MadeGood
MadeGood Granola Bars
8.1
$4VS
Winner
Once Upon a Farm
Once Upon a Farm Refrigerated Oat Bars
8.5
$7R3 Research Verdict
Both deliver on clean ingredients, but Once Upon a Farm edges ahead with just 4-5 whole food ingredients and 3g sugar versus MadeGood's 5g. MadeGood wins on value ($0.72 vs $1.75) and allergen safety. Your choice depends on ingredient purity versus budget and school restrictions.
Updated Jan 29, 20267 attributes comparedBy R3 Research Team
The Verdict
Research-backed recommendation
Once Upon a Farm wins on ingredient purity - you're paying for cold-pressed whole foods with minimal sugar. MadeGood wins on practicality - shelf-stable, allergen-free, and less than half the price. For families prioritizing the cleanest possible ingredients, choose Once Upon a Farm. For everyday lunchboxes at nut-free schools, MadeGood delivers excellent value.
Pros & Cons at a Glance
Quick summary of each product's strengths and weaknesses
MadeGood
MadeGood Granola Bars
Pros
- Better Sugar per Serving
- Better Ingredients Count
- Better Protein
Cons
- Loses on Price per Bar
- Loses on Allergen Safety
- Loses on Refrigeration
Once Upon a Farm
Once Upon a Farm Refrigerated Oat Bars
Winner
Pros
- Better Price per Bar
- Better Allergen Safety
- Better Refrigeration
Cons
- Loses on Sugar per Serving
- Loses on Ingredients Count
- Loses on Protein
Who Wins Each Category?
A quick breakdown of how these products compare head-to-head
Price Per Bar
Once Upon a Farm
Win
MadeGood saves $1+ per bar
Sugar Per Serving
MadeGood
Win
OUAF has 40% less sugar
Ingredients Count
MadeGood
Win
OUAF is simpler
Allergen Safety
Once Upon a Farm
Win
MadeGood safe for all schools
Refrigeration
Once Upon a Farm
Win
MadeGood more convenient
Protein
MadeGood
Win
Modest advantage for OUAF
Organic Certified
Tie
Both USDA Organic
Winner
Tie
Which One Is Right For You?
Personalized recommendations based on your priorities
Buy MadeGood If You...
- Families prioritizing absolute ingredient purity
- Those willing to pay premium for cold-pressed, refrigerated quality
- Parents who want 4-5 recognizable ingredients only
Buy Once Upon a Farm If You...Winner
- Budget-conscious families packing daily lunchboxes
- Anyone with kids at nut-free schools or managing allergies
- Those needing shelf-stable convenience without refrigeration
Head-to-Head Comparison
Detailed attribute-by-attribute breakdown
MadeGood
vs3
Once Upon a Farm
(1 ties)3
| Attribute | MadeGood | Once Upon a Farm | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price per Bar MadeGood saves $1+ per bar | $1.75 | $0.72 | Once Upon a Farm |
| Sugar per Serving OUAF has 40% less sugar | 3g | 5g | MadeGood |
| Ingredients Count OUAF is simpler | 4-5 | 12-15 | MadeGood |
| Allergen Safety MadeGood safe for all schools | Some allergens | Top 9 free | Once Upon a Farm |
| Refrigeration MadeGood more convenient | Required | Shelf-stable | Once Upon a Farm |
| Protein Modest advantage for OUAF | 2g | 1g | MadeGood |
| Organic Certified Both USDA Organic | Yes | Yes | Tie |
MadeGood
3 Wins
Once Upon a Farm
3 Wins
Price per Bar
Once Upon a Farm
$1.75
$0.72
MadeGood saves $1+ per bar
Sugar per Serving
MadeGood
3g
5g
OUAF has 40% less sugar
Ingredients Count
MadeGood
4-5
12-15
OUAF is simpler
Allergen Safety
Once Upon a Farm
Some allergens
Top 9 free
MadeGood safe for all schools
Refrigeration
Once Upon a Farm
Required
Shelf-stable
MadeGood more convenient
Protein
MadeGood
2g
1g
Modest advantage for OUAF
Organic Certified
Tie
Yes
Yes
Both USDA Organic
$Price Analysis
Once Upon a Farm costs 2.4x more per bar. Over 180 school days, that's $315 vs $130 annually. The question: is 40% less sugar and 4-ingredient purity worth $185/year?
Best Time to Buy
Buy Once Upon a Farm for special occasions or when ingredient purity matters most. Use MadeGood for everyday school lunches where allergen-safety and budget win.
Create a free account to preview premium reviews
Get 3 free premium previews per week with a free account
Research-backed product recommendations
Transparent methodology and citations
No ads or affiliate influence
Already have an account? Log in
Independent Research
No sponsored placements. Data-driven verdicts.
1,000+ data points
Updated January 29, 2026
R
R3 Research Team
•Evidence-Based Review BoardOur multidisciplinary team of researchers, parents, and medical advisors dedicated to finding the safest products for your family.
Explore More Comparisons
Find the perfect product with our research-backed head-to-head showdowns.
