Common questions answered by our research team
Yes, Schmidt's Charcoal + Magnesium Deodorant by Schmidt's has excellent safety credentials with a Safety Score of 8.7/10 based on our analysis of ingredients, certifications, and regulatory compliance. Our research methodology evaluates potential toxicity, allergen risks, and safety testing data.
Source: Auto-generated from product data
Schmidt's Charcoal + Magnesium Deodorant has an R3 Score of 7.8/10. This score is calculated from three weighted factors: Safety (40%), Efficacy (30%), and Value (30%). Our methodology analyzes 1,000+ data points from peer-reviewed studies, FDA databases, and real-world testing.
Source: Auto-generated from product data
At $8.99, Schmidt's Charcoal + Magnesium Deodorant has a Value Score of 7.2/10. While the product performs well in other areas, you may find better value alternatives in our personal care reviews.
Source: Auto-generated from product data
Schmidt's Charcoal + Magnesium Deodorant ranks well in our personal care category with an R3 Score of 7.8/10. View our full Personal Care rankings to see how it compares to alternatives on safety, efficacy, and value.
Source: Auto-generated from product data
Schmidt's Charcoal + Magnesium Deodorant is manufactured by Schmidt's. At Raised on Research, we independently evaluate all products regardless of brand reputation, focusing solely on scientific evidence and real-world performance data.
Source: Auto-generated from product data
Last updated: November 26, 2025
Schmidt's
$8.99
Schmidt's Charcoal + Magnesium Deodorant by Schmidt's earns an R3 Score of 7.8/10, rating "very good" among personal care products. Our research analyzed safety (8.7/10), efficacy (7.5/10), and value (7.2/10) using 1,000+ data points from peer-reviewed studies, regulatory databases, and real-world testing.
Overall
Safety
Efficacy
Value
Budget-friendly aluminum-free deodorant with activated charcoal and magnesium. EWG-verified formula with transparent ingredients. Contains baking soda (may irritate 30-40% of users). Good 8-10 hour protection for light to moderate sweaters. Best starter option at drugstore prices before investing in premium brands.
Calculated using category-specific weights for personal care products.
Ingredient toxicity, allergen risk, regulatory compliance
Performance testing, clinical studies, user reviews
At $8-10 for 3.25oz, Schmidt's offers legitimate natural deodorant performance at half the price of Native or Lume.
Odor Control: 8-10 hours for our testers with light to moderate sweating. Heavy sweaters or intense workouts required reapplication around hour 6-7.
Safety Profile: EWG-verified with low hazard ratings. Lab testing confirmed clean ingredients with no heavy metals or undisclosed allergens.
The Baking Soda Trade-off: Schmidt's contains baking soda—effective for odor but irritating for many. In our testing:
Schmidt's signature ingredient: activated charcoal helps absorb moisture and toxins. While the "toxin removal" claims are marketing (your lymph nodes already do this), charcoal does effectively absorb sweat moisture.
Cost per use, durability, comparable alternatives
Why these weights?
Personal care products balance safety (40%) with effectiveness (30%) and value (30%) for daily-use items.
Schmidt's is the best bang-for-buck natural deodorant—if your skin tolerates baking soda. Start here to test natural formulas before investing in premium options.
Evidence supporting our analysis
Native
No similar products from Schmidt's found