The Pharmacokinetics of DEET and Why We Avoid It
N,N-Diethyl-meta-toluamide (DEET) was developed by the U.S. Army in 1946 and became available to the public in 1957. While it is highly effective against Ixodes scapularis (the black-legged tick carrying Lyme disease) and Aedes mosquitoes, its safety profile for developing neurobiology is increasingly questioned by independent toxicologists.
Dermal Penetration & Neurotoxicity: DEET is rapidly absorbed through the stratum corneum. Studies indicate that up to 5-8% of topically applied DEET is absorbed systemically into the bloodstream. Once in the body, it has been shown to inhibit acetylcholinesterase—a crucial enzyme for central nervous system function—in ways similar to organophosphate pesticides. For young children with developing blood-brain barriers, this systemic absorption presents an unnecessary toxic load when safer, equally efficacious alternatives exist.
Furthermore, DEET is a recognized plasticizer—it literally melts synthetic fabrics, watchbands, and sunglasses. If a chemical has the solvent power to dissolve a nylon tent, applying it to a toddler's skin is structurally counter-intuitive to the R3 Clean Living philosophy.
“DEET's ability to act as a plastic-dissolving solvent, combined with systemic dermal absorption rates of up to 8%, makes it an unacceptable risk for pediatric use when 20% Picaridin matches its efficacy.”
— Renee Says
Section Summary
- Systemic absorption: 5-8% of applied DEET enters the bloodstream.
- Enzyme inhibition: DEET interacts with acetylcholinesterase.
- Solvent properties: Readily melts synthetic materials and plastics.
The Gold Standard: Picaridin and Icaridin Mechanics
Picaridin (known chemically as Icaridin or 1-piperidinecarboxylic acid, 2-(2-hydroxyethyl)- 1-methylpropylester) is a synthetic compound modeled after piperine, the alkaloid that gives black pepper its bite. Introduced to the US in 2005, it represents the most significant advancement in repellent chemistry in a half-century.
Receptor Blockade: Unlike insecticides which kill, Picaridin works by blocking the olfactory (smell) receptors on insects. It effectively 'blinds' the mosquito's or tick's ability to detect the carbon dioxide and lactic acid emitted by human skin.
The Efficacy Data: Independent efficacy trials analyzed by the EPA demonstrate that a 20% concentration of Picaridin provides 12 to 14 hours of protection against ticks and 8 to 12 hours against mosquitoes. This heavily rivals or beats 30% DEET. Crucially, the systemic dermal absorption of Picaridin is negligible (less than 1%), and it carries absolutely zero neurotoxic warnings or solvent properties.
Section Summary
- Derived from piperine (black pepper extract).
- Blocks olfactory reception of CO2 and lactic acid.
- 20% concentration provides 12-14 hours of tick protection.
- Systemic absorption is less than 1%.
Botanical Alternatives: Understanding PMD (Oil of Lemon Eucalyptus)
For families insisting on purely botanical solutions, standard essential oils (citronella, cedarwood, peppermint) are woefully inadequate for disease-endemic areas, generally offering only 15 to 30 minutes of protection before volatile evaporation.
The only botanical repellent endorsed by the CDC for disease-carrying insects is Oil of Lemon Eucalyptus (OLE). Specifically, the active compound is p-Menthane-3,8-diol (PMD). PMD is a concentrated extract that has undergone extreme clinical testing, proving it can offer up to 6 hours of mosquito protection.
The Pediatric Caveat: The CDC strongly advises against using OLE/PMD on children under the age of 3. This is because high concentrations of PMD can trigger severe allergic dermatitis and eye irritation in infants. For kids under 3, 20% Picaridin remains the only scientifically sound, non-toxic choice.
Section Summary
- Standard essential oils evaporate too quickly for reliable protection.
- PMD is the only CDC-backed botanical active ingredient.
- OLE/PMD is strictly contraindicated for children under 3 years old.
1 more tips
Create a free account to see more buying advice