The Quick Answer

  • Heavy metals (Lead, Arsenic, Cadmium) are in baby food not because companies maliciously add them, but because they are naturally found in the Earth's crust and water supply. Crops absorb them as they grow. Root vegetables (sweet potatoes, carrots) and rice absorb the highest amounts. You cannot completely eliminate heavy metal exposure, but you can drastically minimize it by feeding your baby a highly diverse diet, rotating grains (oats/quinoa instead of just rice), and avoiding fruit juices entirely.
Editor's NoteThis guidance aligns with the FDA's "Closer to Zero" action plan and toxicological assessments of dietary absorption.

The Source of the Toxins

When a Congressional subcommittee released a report in 2021 showing high levels of heavy metals in popular baby foods (Happy Family, Gerber, Earth's Best), panic ensued.

It is critical to understand the source: Lead, Cadmium, and Arsenic are elements in the earth's soil. Historical pollution (leaded gasoline, old pesticides) enriched the soil with these elements over the last century. When you grow an organic sweet potato, it pulls water and nutrients from the soil to grow. It unavoidably pulls up the heavy metals, too.

Organic certification simply means no synthetic pesticides were sprayed. It has absolutely zero impact on whether the soil underneath contained heavy metals.

“You cannot scrub heavy metals entirely out of agriculture. The goal is relentless minimization through dietary rotation.”

— Renee Says

Section Summary

  • Metals are in the soil and water, absorbed during growth.
  • Organic farming does not prevent heavy metal absorption.
  • Root vegetables and rice are the biggest culprits.

The Rice Problem

Rice is uniquely efficient at absorbing Inorganic Arsenic from soil and water compared to other grains. Because rice is traditionally grown in flooded fields, the water facilitates maximum metal transfer into the plant.

Historically, pediatrician advice was to start infants on Rice Cereal. We now know this is the worst possible advice. Infant rice cereal, rice puffs, and teething rusks are concentrated sources of arsenic. Because infants are so small, their exposure per pound of body weight is dangerously high.

Section Summary

  • Rice absorbs 10x more arsenic than other grains.
  • Skip infant rice cereal entirely.
  • Rice-based teething crackers are high-exposure snacks.

The Bottom Line

  • Do not panic, but do pivot. Stop feeding your baby rice puffs and rice cereal. Rotate root vegetables (give sweet potatoes on Monday, but offer broccoli or avocado on Tuesday). Avoid fruit juices, as metals concentrate in the juice pressing process. The key to heavy metal safety is absolute diet diversity.

1 more tips

Create a free account to see more buying advice

Sign Up Free

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about toxicology: nutrition answered by our research team.

QIs making my own baby food safer?

Not necessarily. If you buy a sweet potato from the grocery store and puree it yourself, it contains the exact same heavy metals as the sweet potato puree in the jar. However, making it yourself avoids processing contamination and often provides fresher nutrients.

QShould I avoid sweet potatoes and carrots entirely?

No. They are packed with essential vitamins. You should simply offer them in rotation. If you serve carrots for lunch, serve green beans or peas for dinner. Do not feed root vegetables three times a day.

R

Renee, R3 Founder

Environmental Toxins Analyst

Renee is the founder of R3 and a lead researcher in environmental toxins. She specializes in translating complex toxicology reports into actionable advice for families.

LinkedInX (Twitter)Editorial Standards